<iframe width=”560” height=”315” src=”
Professor Dumbledore,
I was recently given the privilege of attending the placement ceremony at Hogwarts where a hat was used to determine which house each new incoming student is placed. This is not an inconsequential decision. Each house has its unique culture and specialties that will shape the future of your students. It seems like this important decision should not be left to a fashion statement with the primary purpose of shielding witches from getting sunburned when riding their brooms.
Has Hogwarts evaluated the accuracy of the sorting hat? Do we know the persistence rate of students into their second year based on their house placement? How is it that putting a hat on a student’s head for about six seconds is a reliable way to determine a student’s placement? What if the student was startled by a spirit just before the ceremony or her owl is lost? Those kinds of experiences at the time of assessment could skew the results.
What criteria is the hat using? It was clearly not apparent during the ceremony. Do you explain the criteria in the course catalog? Is it simple for students to understand or is it a complicated algorithm that students will find confusing.
I was surprised that the hat didn’t even ask the student any questions about her goals, what skills she was most interested in, and what position in the Hogwarts universe they wish to hold? It seems like students are reliant on a very arbitrary process to determine their path. It appears to be that Hogwarts is a slave to its traditions, maintaining the position that this is how they have always done it.
May I suggest an alternative approach. Students should be warmly greeted at Platform 9 3/4 by a representative from Hogwarts. Upon boarding Hogwarts Express, students should be given information about the various houses at Hogwarts and a scheduled appointment to meet with an advisor. The Hogwarts Express should dedicate a car to each of the four houses and give students an opportunity to talk with a representative so they can ask questions, understand the requirements, and learn about the unique features of each house so they can consider how each house aligns with their career goals.
Upon arrival, students participate in an orientation and ultimately meet with an advisor. At that point the student reviews her academic record and discusses the choice of the house with their advisor. In the end, the student selects the house of their choice. If a student needs additional support to be fully prepared for life in their new house, it should be provided along side their first semester courses.
This appears to be a more sensible and transparent process. I submit this as a recommendation for your consideration. If you would like to discuss this further, please send an owl to the enclosed address with a time and place for us to discuss.
As for the hat, I understand that a lot of money can be made in prediction markets by betting on Quidditch matches. I think it could make a lot of galleons
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Yours Truly and Happy Halloween,
Bruce Vandal, Muggle at Bruce Vandal Consulting.